{Of all lies, art is the least untrue - Flaubert}



Tuesday, August 07, 2007

Bergman at Chicago

This weekend Chicago Cinema Forum has a two day tribute (Aug 11-12, '07) to Bergman at Chopin Theatre. First film at the tribute, Sawdust and Tinsel, will be introducted by Jonathan Rosenbaum, who only yesterday trashed Bergman's whole career in New York Times. World is full of irony. Anyway, if my fever is ok, I will be there, at least for the first day, because it shows two of Bergman films that I haven't seen yet.
And please vist Greencine Daily Bergman Link, it is a nice compilation of the recent articles and posts on Bergman.

मंटो की कहानियाँ

इस सप्ताहांत मैं सआदत हसन मंटो की कुछ कहानिया पढ़ रह था। शिकागो library में हिंदी की किताबो का अच्छा संग्रह है। वहीँ मैंने एक किताब देखी, जिसका शीर्षक था - मंटो की यथाकथित विवादित कहानियाँ। इस संकलन में मंटो की सात कहानिया हें, जिनमें से छः पर अश्लीलता का मुकदमा चला था। मंटो सभी में बरी हो गए थे। संकलन के शुरुआत में मंटो का लिखा एक लेख है - मंटो अपनी नज़र में - जिसमे सआदत हसन, मंटो का हमजाद (जिन्न) बन कर , मंटो की पोल खोलता है, बताता है की मंटो अफ़साने कैसे लिखता था, और वोह एक नंबर का फ्रोड क्यों है, पर असल में वो कहता है की चाहे मंटो बुरा आदमी हो, उसे अव्वल दर्ज़ा उर्दू ना आती हो, पर वो अपनी कहानियो में वो ही दिखाता है जो वोह अपने आस पास देखता है।

मैं मंटो की कहानियो पर कुछ लिखने की सोच रह था पर उनपर तर्क वितर्क लिखना थोडा मुश्किल सा लगा , कहीँ सही शब्द नहीं मिले तो कही सही तरह से उन्हें बताने का कोई तरीका नहीं सुझा। मंटो की कहानियो में अश्लीलता केवल शब्दो तक है, पर उनके पीछे जो भाव छुपा है वोह बहुत संवेदनशील और इमानदार हें। मंटो की कहानियो को खुरदुरा कहा जा सकता है, उन में जिस भाषा और बोली का इस्तेमाल है, जिस तरह मानसिक और शारीरिक स्थिती के वर्णन को मिला दिया गया है, उस से एक विशेष प्रकार का अनुभव होता है, जो इन्सान के जिस्म से जुडा है और उसकी भावनाओं से भी, उसी तरह जिस तरह एक अच्छी कहानी दार्शनिक होकर भी मिटटी से जुडी रहती है। मंटो विभाजन के दुःख से कोई सस्ती सहनाभुती नहीं बटोरता , पर बड़े ही कम लफ्जो में उस क्रूरता को दर्शा देता है। बिल्कुल उसी तरह वोह किस्सी वेश्या को उसके काम से नहीं देखता, पर उसके इंसानी इच्छाओ पर चिन्तन करता है। मेरी नज़र में इस संकलन की सबसे बेहतरीन कहानी 'हतक' है, जिसमे हमारी नायिका सुगंधि एक ग्राहक के नापसंद किये जाने पर जिस पीड़ा और अपमान के गुजरती है, वो मंटो ने बहुत सही चित्रित किया है। जब सुगंधि , सेठ के जाने के बाद, अँधेरी सुनसान सड़क पर आधीरात में खडी होती है, तो मंटो ने उसके मन में आने वाले एक एक विचार को किस्सी रहस्य की तरह खोला है, जो अंत में उसकी नियति की और इशारा करता है। मंटो की एक और कहानी 'काली सलवार' में मंटो ने मन में चलने वाले विचारो और आस पास के वातावरण को यु बुन दिया है जैसे वास्तव में वो एक ही हो, और उसपर ये भी जाहिर कर दिया है की यह सब आज ऐसा इसलिये लग रह है, क्योंकि सोचने वाले के मन की स्तिथी आज ऐसी है। मैं और कुछ ज्यादा नहीं लिख पा रहा हूँ , तो अंत में मंटो की कहानी 'हतक' से यह अंश लिख रह हूँ, जो साफ साफ मंटो की छाप लिए हुये है।

वो रूपये जो उसने अपने शारीरिक परिश्रम के बदले दरोगा से वसूल किये थे, उसकी चुस्त और थूक से भारी चोली के नीचे से ऊपर उभरे हुये थे, कभी कभी सांस के उतार चढ़ाव से चादी के यह सिक्के खनकने लगते थे, तो उनकी खनखनाहट उसके दिल की बेमेल धडकानो में घुलमिल जाती , ऐसा मालूम होता की इन सिक्को की चांदी पिघल कर उसके दिल के ख़ून में टपक रही है।

मंटो की बहुचर्चित कहानी टोबा टेक सिंह आप हिंदी में यहाँ पढ़ सकते हें। यहाँ मंटो की पांच लघु कहानिया पढ़ सकते हें।

Monday, August 06, 2007

Random Respite...

When we have nothing much to write, we usually tend towards two basic things, one is nature and the second one is childhood. Both, in their unique way provide momentary respite from our self-induced ennui and boredom. To write about nature requires exceptional skills and a good knowledge. So the lesser mortals turn towards their childhoods, in a attempt to relive it as we did it then, and sip some more nectar, attach some more nostalgia with self serving imagination of the good old past. I, as a child, had always met with the feeling of other worldliness and wonder, when I used to see the pictures of the loved ones taken before my birth. Whatever we may call it, it was a feeling that it all existed when you didn't. Although a Hindu upbringing try to put things in perspective with you being somewhere else in your earlier birth, but those photographs were a proof that you are just new entry to the whole system. In my stupid imagination routine, I have wondered what it would be like when we die, will we hover over the skies and try to find out what every body felt about the loss (?), or just die out and be as non-existent as we were before our birth. I know that memories will last in the minds of certain people but it cant help but wonder at the exactitude of the childhood feeling of you being not there at some point in time, and the world was, as you saw in those picture, same and as good.

One of my earliest childhood memories is of a wedding in Moradabad, and I remember very vividly that it was all crowded and my mother was always leaving me with some old lady. When I ask about that wedding now, I am told that I was just over one at that time, but it is one of most clear of the childhood memories, the next clear one is not till I turn three, and then comes the school and a whole new world into picture. I wonder how some authors remember things with such exactness, with names and colors and flavors. I only remember the collections of memory, like a bunch with all the morning walks to company garden and a bunch with all the mosquito-filled nights. I have never thought what time and stuff means to me, but I know, although it feel like free flowing ,its like an arrest in a big prison. Except for some exceptional times, you never cross the same thing in the prison park, the same way the second time, but you can, with time, relate to the vicinities and identify them with smell, color and touch. Any attempt to trace back to the same old happy point, results in chaos and the knowledge that its not possible.

The first dream, or the most recurrent dream of childhood is quite vague and as I try to recall now, it happens to be a cold foggy early morning and our village house is attacked by some weird ghostlike people. I get out of my bed and go to the first floor and stand near the point where I can (over)see them but they cant see me. They roam and from my strategic position, I try to call my parents and grandmother to be alert, but no one listens to me. The monsters, after the inspection, go away. The later dreams involve face to face encounter and the sudden break of sleep and finding by mother nearby, and the versions where monster took faces of some of the deadly teachers and some of beautiful ones standing by me. Later in life, I have stopped dreaming, the sleep looks like a blink with the waking point mixed with the tension to go to work, and actually I have even tried to redream (my mother told me as a child that what you think just before your sleep come to you in your dream) the monster dream, but without success. Now dreams are an occasional affair and they are more convoluted, they don't follow a pattern and I am not a hero fighting monsters in house with beautiful teachers backing me.

Friday, August 03, 2007

We are Morons - Lovers of Death and Depression !

And here are reasons why Bergman and the likes never mattered to some.

An apt reply here, where he coins a term called Derrièrism defined as following:

Derrièrists are tired of liberal elites telling us what is good for us. They are tired of movies that are depressing and pretentious and difficult. They don't see the need for new narrative structures when the old ones work just fine. They believe that films should be as literal and clear as the Bible. They are tired of movies that always focus on the bad news the way the media always focuses on the bad news from Iraq. And they prefer clearly resolved, preferably happy, endings.

(Links via)

I didn't find on youtube but there is an excellent scene in The Seventh Seal where the knight sits with a family and have milk and strawberries and says "I shall remember this moment: the silence, the twilight, the bowl of strawberries, the bowl of milk. Your faces in the evening light. Mikael asleep, Jof with his lyre. I shall try to remember our talk. I shall carry this memory carefully in my hands as if it were a bowl brimful of fresh milk. It will be a sign to me, and a great sufficiency". Mr Podhoret should see that scene because he claims that the entire oeuvre of Bergman does not have even a single happy moment. I know it wont help, his "happy" ass still might not fit the seat.

Thursday, July 05, 2007

Few Links, Few Lines

1. Manasi pointed to this awesome essay by Virginia Woolf. The Woolf's Middlebrow is quite like the Nabokov's Poshlust-guy. In a way, there is nothing so new in this essay but it does put lots of things in place.

2. Bruce Baillie's short Valentin de Las Sierras was amazingly poetic and lyrical. Here are some of his films including his most famous short Castro Street.

3. A very nice review of a bad film, insightful and never going over the top or banal. I liked the phase "Our Lady of Humanitarian Narcissism". Here is the poster, this review talks about.

4. This is a nice piece of music.

5. A long discussion about American Film Noir. I haven't read it fully though.

6. Saw three excellent films, Ordet, Beau Travail and Do the Right Thing. Planning to write about them. Nice writeups here, here and here, resp.

7. I have been planning to see Battle in Heaven for long, here's a long interview with the director.

8. Gene Siskel centre is screening Boss of it all on Friday. I am looking forward to it. It will be showing Inland Empire two times this month, one would have to go both times to make something out of it. And here is my chance to see Mulholland Drive on big screen. Other film to look forward to is Into Great Silence.

9. If you have Internet than you cant make any excuse not to watch the excellent documentary The Corporation (Part 1 and Part 2). And if you still have any guilt while using p2p file sharing, see this :)

10. On the same site, you can find most of Byomkesh Bakshi too.

11. Film Director Edward Yang died of colon cancer last Friday. I have Yi yi in my collection for long, will see it on this weekend. GreenCine Daily has lots of links about him.